Navigating the black box of fair national emissions targets
- Hakan Sener
- Jul 16
- 3 min read
Updated: Jul 30
A 2025 study reveals how fairness principles, global strategy, and science shape national emissions targets and climate finance needs.
In July 2025, Mark M. Dekker and a team of researchers from PBL Netherlands Environmental Assessment Agency, Utrecht University, and other institutions published a study that dives deep into how “fair” national emissions targets can be calculated—and why doing so is so complex. As countries gear up to submit updated nationally determined contributions (NDCs) under the Paris Agreement in 2025, this study offers a timely and systematic evaluation of equity in climate action.
The study addresses the lack of transparency and consistency in the allocation of emissions allowances across nations. It confronts the "black box" of effort-sharing models and introduces a unified framework that accounts for three main dimensions: scientific uncertainties, global political strategies, and normative fairness principles. The goal: to provide more equitable, science-based national targets and assess the gaps between current commitments and fair shares.
Key Findings: What Makes a Target Fair?
Three Dimensions Shape Fair Emissions Targets
The authors categorize all variables influencing emissions targets into:
Scientific Uncertainties (e.g. climate sensitivity, socioeconomic scenarios),
Global Strategies (e.g. temperature targets, mitigation timing),
Normative Considerations (e.g. equity principles like capability, responsibility, and equality).
Each country’s fair share is affected differently by these categories. For instance, Nigeria’s allocation is shaped mostly by equity principles due to its low historical emissions and GDP, while China’s is strongly influenced by how historical emissions are accounted for.
Comparing Targets Against NDCs and Cost-Optimal Pathways
Under default assumptions (limiting warming to 1.6°C), the global emissions gap in 2030 is 13.9 GtCO₂e—double the gap assessed by current policies.
Many nations, including Russia, Saudi Arabia, and the USA, exceed their fair emissions allowances.
India and Nigeria, by contrast, often receive allowances greater than their current NDCs, reflecting their low historical emissions and income levels.
The Bill: International Climate Finance
To bridge the gap between current NDCs and fair shares, the paper estimates that international climate finance will need to reach $0.5–7.4 trillion in 2030. High-income countries with stringent fair targets but high cost-optimal emissions, like the USA and the EU, are expected to finance mitigation abroad.
Emphasis on Policy Transparency
Through the use of Sobol variance decomposition, the authors dissect which factors most influence a country’s target. This transparency helps policymakers understand the consequences of choosing specific fairness rules or global targets. It also warns against cherry-picking favorable models.
Why This Study Matters
This is one of the most comprehensive attempts to date to quantify fair national emissions targets and explain why they differ so much depending on chosen principles. It lays the groundwork for more credible and equitable climate negotiations, especially as the 2025 NDC revision cycle looms.
It also reinforces a key message: equity is not optional in climate policy. Without considering fairness explicitly, national targets will continue to reflect power asymmetries rather than shared global responsibility.
Unpacking the “Black Box” of Climate Fairness
This study cuts through the complexity of equitable national emissions targets, providing policymakers and negotiators with a transparent, actionable framework. Its public database and detailed methodology will inform upcoming climate pledges and finance mechanisms.
As climate action moves forward, understanding the “how” and “why” behind emissions allocations is critical. Fairness isn't just an ethical imperative—it’s a practical one.
Sign up for our newsletter or connect with us on social media to stay up-to-date with our latest posts and permaculture inspiration.
Explore our inspiring series and posts:
Love the post? Share it with your circle, inspire your people.