A 2023 study finds humanity has breached six of nine planetary boundaries, increasing risks of global instability and urgent need for action.
The planetary boundaries framework, first introduced in 2009 and refined in 2015, defines critical Earth system limits to ensure a stable and resilient planet. This 2023 study, led by Katherine Richardson and co-authored by leading Earth system scientists, presents an updated assessment, revealing that humanity has now transgressed six of the nine planetary boundaries—a stark indication that we are operating far outside the safe space for human civilization.
Key Findings: The State of Planetary Boundaries
The study assesses all nine planetary boundaries and their current status:
Climate Change (Breached)
CO₂ levels have risen to 417 ppm, well above the safe limit of 350 ppm.
The total radiative forcing is +2.91 W/m², exceeding the boundary of +1.0 W/m², pushing Earth toward dangerous climate tipping points.
Biosphere Integrity (Breached)
The extinction rate is at least 100 E/MSY, ten times the safe limit of 10 E/MSY.
Functional biodiversity is also deteriorating, with human activity appropriating 30% of global net primary production (NPP)—surpassing the new biosphere integrity boundary set at 10% HANPP (Human Appropriation of Net Primary Production).
Biogeochemical Flows: Nitrogen & Phosphorus (Breached)
Nitrogen pollution is at 190 Tg/year, exceeding the planetary limit of 62 Tg/year.
Phosphorus pollution is at 22.6 Tg/year, surpassing the safe boundary of 11 Tg/year. These excess nutrients disrupt ecosystems, causing ocean dead zones and freshwater eutrophication.
Land-System Change (Breached)
Global forest cover has dropped to 60%, below the safe threshold of 75%.
The Amazon has now transgressed its biome-specific boundary, increasing risks of tipping toward savannization.
Freshwater Use (Breached)
The study introduces green water (soil moisture) as an essential component of this boundary.
Both blue water (surface and groundwater use) and green water are now beyond safe limits, with deviations exceeding preindustrial variability.
Novel Entities (Breached)
The boundary for chemical pollution—including plastics, microplastics, PFAS, and synthetic chemicals—has been transgressed.
Only ~20% of chemicals in commercial use have undergone comprehensive safety testing.
Stratospheric Ozone (Safe, Recovering)
The ozone boundary remains within the safe zone, with concentrations at 284.6 DU, close to the preindustrial level of 290 DU, thanks to the success of the Montreal Protocol.
Ocean Acidification (Approaching Breach)
The safe limit is 80% of preindustrial aragonite saturation; current levels are at 81%, nearing the threshold.
Atmospheric Aerosol Loading (Regionally Breached)
The global average remains within safe limits, but South Asia, China, and other regions exceed the safe level of 0.1 AOD, impacting monsoon stability and regional climates.
Implications: A Systemic Earth Crisis
The study underscores that transgressing multiple planetary boundaries at once creates cascading effects and systemic risks:
Climate change worsens biodiversity loss, land degradation, and freshwater scarcity.
Deforestation weakens carbon sinks, accelerating warming and disrupting the water cycle.
Excess nitrogen and phosphorus drive oceanic dead zones, impacting biosphere integrity.
Unlike previous assessments, this study introduces a risk-based framework that categorizes planetary boundaries into zones of increasing risk rather than a simple binary assessment of "safe" or "breached". This reflects the compounding threats facing the Earth system.
Policy and Action Recommendations
Immediate Climate Action
Rapid CO₂ reductions to restore concentrations below 350 ppm.
Stronger policies to prevent runaway global warming and tipping points.
Global Biodiversity Protection
Expanding protected areas and halting deforestation, particularly in tropical regions like the Amazon.
Strengthening international biodiversity agreements to restore ecosystem integrity.
Reduce Pollution and Novel Entities
Stricter regulation on chemical production, microplastics, and persistent pollutants.
Implement circular economy principles to minimize waste and toxic substances.
Water Management and Land-Use Reforms
Reducing freshwater overuse and improving soil moisture conservation.
Restoring degraded lands to enhance climate resilience.
Conclusion: A Call for Systemic Change
The 2023 update to the planetary boundaries framework provides a stark warning: humanity has already destabilized six of nine critical Earth system processes, increasing the risk of crossing tipping points. While some areas, such as ozone recovery, offer hope, urgent systemic action is needed to prevent irreversible planetary change.
This study reinforces the importance of integrated Earth system governance—treating planetary crises not as isolated issues but as interconnected challenges requiring holistic, urgent action at all levels of society.
Sign up for our newsletter or connect with us on social media to stay up-to-date with our latest posts and permaculture inspiration.
Explore our inspiring series and posts:
Love the post? Share it with your circle, inspire your people: